“Clergy/Laity”: Good or Bad for the Body of Christ?

clergyDoes the New Testament teach that there is a separate class of church leaders designated as ‘clergy’ who are over the ‘laity’?  Is it biblical? Is it helpful?

The idea is that the pulpit and other church work can only be occupied by certain people – the “clergy”. The rest – the “laity” – sit in pews. In this dichotomy is a system of doing ministry whether Catholic, Protestant, or otherwise. In a nutshell: the “clergy” are paid to give and the “laymen” pay in order to receive. This distinction permeates our religious vocabulary, and unfortunately captures the heart of our practice: we pay the “clergy” to do the necessary religious activities.

This practice of dividing God’s people into two classes – pulpiteers and pew-sitters. It is a pattern that certainly reflects the hierarchical patterns of the world, but which does not square with New Testament teaching.

In fact some would argue that the New Testament is actually against the class system such a “clergy” class. James D. G. Dunn suggests that this class system does more to undermine the canonical authority of the New Testament than other heresies.

The Clergy’s job to keep the religious machinery going means the expectations are very high for those who wear the many hats this profession demands.

The deadly problem with this unscriptural system is that it eats up those within this role. Burnout, moral lapse, divorce, and suicide are very high among the “clergy.” Its why 1500 pastors leave the ministry each month[i] Is it any wonder such repeated tragedies occur in light of what is expected of one person? Christ never intended anyone to fill such an ecclesiastical role. In light of Paul’s remark in 1 Cor. 12:14 that “the body is not one part but many“, we should be able to discern that the “clergy” position is neither healthy for those in it, nor is it beneficial for the body of Christ.

While the “clergy/laity” distinction is embedded and assumed in religious circles, it cannot be found in the New Testament. It reared up its ugly head in the second and third century, long after Christ’s apostles died.

The New Testament teaches leadership among the people of God, but not in a way that leads to the “clergy/laity” conclusion. The root words from which we derive the English words “clergy” and “laity” are found in the New Testament, but our usage of “clergy/laity” is far removed from the New Testament concepts.

Let’s consider the Biblical uses of these words.  The Greek form of the word “clergy” is “kleros”, which means “heritage, inheritance, lot, part” The Greek form of the word “laity” is “laos”, which means”people”.

So kleros and laos are clearly Biblical concepts.  But there is no suggestion in scripture that the kleros are a class or group of persons distinct  or higher  than the laos.

EARLY CHURCH HISTORY

So when did this unbiblical distinction between clergymen and lay persons come about?

Church historian Charles Jacobs, in The Story of the Church, writes:  “In the beginning most of the work of the congregation was done by people who had no official position.  It was voluntary service, freely rendered.  By the middle of the third century, it was done by the professional clergy.  Between clergymen and laity there was a sharp distinction.  The clergy, too, were divided into higher and lower grades. In the higher grades were bishops, presbyters and deacons; in the lower grade sub-deacons, lectors, exorcists, acolytes and janitors.  All of them were inducted into office by some form of ordination, and the idea of local organization had gone so far that in some churches even the grave diggers were ordained.  Thus the work of the Church was passing out of the hands of the many into those of the few, and these few were coming to be regarded as belonging to a higher class.”

Let us simply gather and serve in the name of Jesus, all Christ followers are God’s people (laos) and His inheritance (cleros).  Jesus is our great High Priest, our Head, our Teacher, and our Savior.

 

When I was facing burnout early in ministry, this verse helped ground me.

 “It was he who gave some to be apostles, some to be prophets, some to be evangelists, and some to be pastors and teachers, to prepare God’s people for ministry  so that the body of Christ may be built up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ.  Ephesians 4:11-13

Ministry is not done by a few but shared by all. Then we are all built up, have unity and maturity in Christ!

Darrell  www.RidgeFellowship.com

PS  There is still work to be done, but I want to do all I can to erase the class system by:

* Not use “Reverend” and other religious titles that reflect the “clergy/laity” distinction, or wear clothing that separates me from others: collars, robes, etc.

* Seeing myself as part of the “laos” people of God along with everyone else, for the good of the body (1 Cor. 12:7).

* Reminding others that “Clergy” roles and all the expectations that go with them are based on human traditions and not the gospel.

* Instructing that all aspects of caring for one another rest with the body, not on some spiritual elite.

* Moving away from “clergy” spoon-feeding the “laity”, to encouraging study/reading together from the Word and acting upon it. (Growth Groups!)

* Adopting a teaching style where dialogue can occur, testimonies, stories of life change and questions/insight from others are encouraged.

*Shifting in the way “church” is done from dependency on one person to creating participation from many.

For more information and history about Clergy and Laity see the sources below.

Sources:
The Distinction between Clergy and Laity – Is it of God?  By Steven Hesterman
http://www.plymouthbrethren.com/clergy.htm
The “Clergy/Laity” Distinction: A Help or a Hindrance to the Body of Christ?  By Jon Zens
http://www.searchingtogether.org/articles/clergylaity.htm

About dkoop

Lead Pastor of Upwards Church: Leander, Jarrell & Taylor, TX
This entry was posted in Church and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to “Clergy/Laity”: Good or Bad for the Body of Christ?

  1. Tom Suchy says:

    Greetings D Koop. Thank you for writing about the unbiblical distinction between “Clergy” and “laity” and I commend you for taking measures to erase this class system. I have served as a missionary in Mongolia for over twenty years and the issue of how money can be used in a wise way to help expand Christ’s Kingdom in a cross-cultural context has been very important to me. Related to this is of course the “Clergy-Laity” distinction that is so prevalent in our ecclesiology and thus our missiology as well. I have become convinced that for the gospel of Christ to have greater impact in our context where Christianity is losing traction there must be a movement with no paid ministers. It is my understanding that one of, if not the main, facilitator for the elevation of clergy, as well as one of, if not the main distinguishing feature of the division of clergy and laity is, financial compensation. Clergy receive pay for their ministry and laity are volunteers. I would be curious to know your thoughts on this. After reading your article and then seeing your designation as “Lead Pastor” it made me think that you probably receive a salary and that ministry is your vocation. (By the way, I am an ordained pastor and receive my livelihood for ministry so I am not knocking paid pastors. I am just sincerely wondering how to reconcile my own growing convictions about professionally paid clergy and my own situation.) If I am wrong I would be interested in knowing how your fellowship is organized and functions without paid staff. However, if I am correct, I would be interested in knowing how you square your teaching about the unbiblical-ness of the clergy-laity distinction and your practice of pastoring as a paid professional. Thanks for any thoughts you might have to share in this regard. A fellow servant of Jesus Christ, Tom Suchy

    • dkoop says:

      Good thoughts Tom! I do, like you receive compensation for doing ministry which I consider a huge blessing not a right or expectation. I agree with your convictions and am prepared to teach school or start a business at anytime. I find myself kept pretty busy equipping a growing number of volunteer ministers, group leaders and pastors to teach at 2 other church locations in two other communities we serve in. Darrell

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s